What do guys think after the first date? (17 common things)

We sometimes include products we think are useful for our readers. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission. Read our affiliate disclosure.


Do you think after the first date, guys are more likely to stay in a relationship or move on?

If you’re considering dating a guy, it’s time to start thinking about what guys think after the first date. 

The first time around, you might be wondering if he’s into you. 

Do you two have similar interests? Did he have a good time? Is he interested in you?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to the question, “what do guys think after the first date?”, but there are some general things you should keep in mind. 

So, here are 17 common things men think after the first date.

17 common things men think after the first date

1) Did she have a good time?

The first thing guys think after the first date is whether or not the date was a success.

  • Did she have fun?
  • Did he make her laugh?
  • Did she have a good time?
  • Was it worth all of his time and effort?
  • Did he do something fun, interesting, and exciting enough to keep her interested?
  • Did he make sure to ask about things that are important to her (i.e. family, friends, job, etc.)?

If it was a good date for you, then chances are you’ll want to go on another one… or at least give him another chance. 

The truth is, after the first date, guys are always wondering if you had a good time.

If the date was bad, it’s likely that he’ll want to cut his losses and move on.

2) Did she like me?

Guys think, “did she like me?” after the first date because they’re wondering if you liked them enough to want to go out with them again. 

They’re concerned about whether or not they did something stupid to turn you off, or whether or not they should have done something differently in order to get you more interested in them. 

But let’s be honest.

Women are much more complicated than guys think, and there’s no surefire way for him to know for sure if you like him. 

But, if you’re interested in him and you want to go out with him again, then you’ll make it a point to tell him what you liked about the date. 

Either way, chances are that he’s going to ask you about it. 

I tell you what though. 

If he doesn’t ask you what he can do differently or what you liked about the date, then he’s not interested. 

You can take that as your cue to move on.

3) Was I really acting like a hero?

Want to hear a secret?

Sometimes guys come to the realization that they’re not as cool, smooth, or charming as they thought they were.

And guess what?

There’s a new theory in the relationship world that’s causing quite a stir – it’s called the hero instinct

Coined by relationship expert James Bauer, this fascinating concept finally explains how men really think and feel in relationships. 

And it’s something most women have never even heard of. 

According to James Bauer, men don’t actually need a lot to feel content in their relationships. To most people’s surprise, it has nothing to do with sex.

You see, men have innate drivers. These are natural responses that they’re not even aware of. But when a woman comes along and triggers them, it causes a powerful response. 

The result is a man who loves harder, commits wholeheartedly, and truly dedicates himself to the relationship. 

So, how can you trigger your man’s hero instinct? 

Well, you certainly don’t need to act like a damsel in distress or buy him a cape. It’s quite simple, actually. 

All you have to do is give your man certain signals that make him feel needed in the relationship. These allow him to step to the plate and feel fulfilled in his role as your partner.

And these signals are revealed in this simple and genuine video by James Bauer

The truth is, once you understand how the hero instinct works, there’s no telling what heights your relationship can reach. 

So if you want to give your man what he truly wants from you, make sure to check out James Bauer’s excellent video. In it, he reveals the exact texts and phrases you can use straight away.

Here’s a link to the free video again.

4) I think I she’s not my type

You know what?

I have to admit that I’m a little surprised by this one. 

Because of the fact that…

Over half of all marriages start online these days, and it’s easy to see why. 

When you’re meeting someone for the first time, you don’t really know what you’re getting yourself into. And when it comes to dating or going on a date, things can get awkward. You never really know how the other person is going to act or behave. 

So if there are any red flags or warning signs, then you might not pick them up until it’s too late. 

But online dating is different because there’s a lot more information about the person. So if you’re going to meet up with them, you’ll have a much better idea of what to expect. And this gives you a chance to make sure that they are actually going to be compatible with you.

So in this case, I would say that it’s a good thing that the man told you that he wasn’t attracted to you before things got serious. 

But in real life, it’s a little different.

Because you can’t really tell if someone is going to be a good partner for you until you’ve actually spent time with them. And if they are a bad match, then it might take a while to figure that out.

So if you’re on a date with a guy, it’s best to just relax and see how things go.

5) She has nice eyes, but I don’t really like her personality or sense of humor

This one is a little bit different, but it’s still something that men say.

And to be honest, I can’t really blame them. Because if you’re on a date with someone, you don’t really know them yet.

What does it mean?

This means that you can’t really tell whether they are compatible with you or not.

And so if they are not your type, then it’s probably best to just let them go.

I know you’ve heard the advice a million times but if you’re not really sure about someone, then you shouldn’t waste your time on them. Because if you do end up having a relationship with them, then it’s only going to be a short-term one.

And chances are that it’s not what you want.

6) I hope she doesn’t call me again… or maybe she will?

Let’s face it. Guys are a little bit complicated when it comes to dating.

Most of the time, they hesitate a lot to call you back. Or at the very least, they send you a text message to say that they don’t want to see you again.

So why do men have such trouble with this?

Well, I think that it’s because when a guy likes a girl, he wants her to like him back. And so he’ll do anything in his power to make her happy and keep her around as long as possible.

And in the end, it just doesn’t work out because she ends up not liking him back. And so if he lets her go too easily and doesn’t chase after her, then she might think that he’s not interested in her. And then she’ll never call him again.

This is just one of those things that men sometimes have to deal with when they are dating women.

So what’s it all mean?

Don’t take it personally if a guy doesn’t call you back or tells you that he doesn’t want to see you again. It’s just how men are wired and there is nothing you can do about it.

7) She’s not the girl of my dreams, but I like her.

Here, this is something that every man says when they first meet a woman who they are interested in.

What does it mean?

Let me explain.

When a guy says this, it means that he thinks that you could be a potential girlfriend.

But at the same time, he’s not sure about it. And so he doesn’t want to jump into anything too soon.

And so he wants to take things slow until he can really see if you’re really the girl for him.

Now, I’ll tell you something important.

Sometimes all you need to do is to change one little thing in your appearance, and then a guy will notice you.

You need to make sure that you look good, but not too good. And so I’m going to tell you what changes can help you. But this little trick doesn’t always work.

The truth is, understanding men is much easier than most women realize – we tend to overcomplicate things a lot.

I learned this from relationship expert Carlos Cavallo. He’s one of the world’s leading experts on relationship psychology and what men want from a relationship.

In this free video, he’ll explain everything you need to know about how to get through to your man.

8) I’m not looking for anything serious.

Most men say this when they are still in the process of getting to know a woman.

And you know what?

Most men say this because they aren’t looking for anything serious.

And so he doesn’t want to commit himself to anyone yet.

But at the same time, he doesn’t want to let her down either. And so he’s just not sure what to do. And so his mind is going a million miles an hour and he just can’t make up his mind about what to do next.

But surprisingly, sometimes they are just trying to see if you are the right woman for them.

They want to make sure that you’re a girl who is not looking for something serious. They don’t want to be the man who ends up getting hurt because of his mistake.

So, it’s only natural for them to say this.

But at the same time, it doesn’t mean that they don’t want anything serious from you.

It just means that they have a lot of other things in their life going on, and so they need time to figure out if you’re really the one for them or not.

9) How can I see her again?

Now let’s take it somewhere awesome.

Many guys think that after the first date, you didn’t like him enough to agree to the next date.

And guess what? They feel desperate. Desperate enough to do anything to get you back.

As a result, he might come and ask you if you can get together again.

And this is the moment when you have to make your move.

You need to be able to make him feel that he’s the only one you are interested in. And so, you have to make him feel that it is already a done deal.

This way, he won’t be able to go anywhere else.

And so you’ll be able to get his phone number and call him up whenever you want.

10) We should just keep talking.

Sadly, in every relationship, there will come a time when things start going badly.

That’s why you shouldn’t be surprised if he tells you that your relationship can’t go on and you just need to keep talking because he still likes you.

Sounds complicated, right?

It will seem even more complicated when he suddenly stops talking to you. So, you should be ready for any scenario!

Now you may wonder: why is he doing this?

The answer is simple: maybe it makes him feel like a hero.

I mentioned this fascinating concept earlier: the hero instinct. When a man’s inner hero is triggered, he’s more likely to act more confidently towards you.

Just by knowing the right things to say to him, you’ll open a part of him that no woman has ever reached before.

And the easiest way to do so is by watching this free video by James Bauer. In it, he’ll reveal simple phrases and texts you can use to make your man truly yours. 

Here’s a link to the excellent video again.

11) I feel like I should have done something differently.

Now let me say this straight.

If you think that your first day wasn’t ideal, don’t worry because maybe it wasn’t the right time and place.

Maybe he’s not the right person for you.

And that’s all there is to it!

You didn’t do anything wrong! 

You just don’t have the chemistry you thought you had. And that’s okay because there are a lot of other guys out there that would love to be with someone like you.

Just make sure you’re always yourself and never try to change yourself for someone else. That’s not how relationships work. You can’t be someone else for anyone else, no matter who they are or what their name is! (And if you know this already, then good for you!) .

So, just know that the only person you need to take care of is yourself. And that’s all you need to know.

12) I don’t know what I want.

Wait a minute. isn’t this something all the girls feel after the first date?

No. In fact, it’s something that guys feel too.

The truth is that every person has different needs and wants. You can’t just assume that you know what the other person wants.

Don’t worry, it’s normal. Everyone goes through a phase where they’re not sure what they want in life. And it’ll pass. In fact, it’s a good thing!

So if you notice that he’s not certain bout his feelings, don’t think too much about it and just go with the flow and enjoy this new experience!

13) She’s too tall/short for me.

If you thought that appearance doesn’t really matter, then you’re mistaken.

It’s true.

Most people think that a woman needs to be tall and thin to be attractive. But now let’s put it another way.

What if you’re taller than he is?

If that’s the case, he would want to feel taller next to you. And guess what?

If he doesn’t like the way you look, then he’ll just have to deal with it! If you’re not happy with yourself, then there’s nothing else you can do.

14) I’m not into her.

Whether you like it or not, the first date isn’t always as successful as we imagined.

Sometimes things just don’t go as planned. You might have a great time, but he might not.

Or maybe, you ruined the entire date by being too aggressive or too clingy.

And another scenario is that he had a great time, but you didn’t, but that’s not what we’re discussing right now.

The truth is, one simple date might make him think that he’s not into you. Whether it was your look that he didn’t like or you didn’t impress him, the result is that he’s not into you. Or at least, he thinks like this.

That’s why it’s important to have fun on the first date, but still, give him space. And when he does make the move, at least be ready for it.

15) Was she interested in me?

After the first date, guys also wonder if you were interested in them. 

let me guess. If you gave him a hard time or put him through some tests, then he’s going to think that you’re not very interested in him. 

But he’s wrong, right?

You liked him more than you could have imagined and now you wonder if he liked you as much. 

So, what can you do about it?

Just talk to each other. You can ask him if he liked you, but don’t hold back on asking him.

16) I’m too good for her.

Well, if you thought that guys were so simple and easy to understand, then this one might surprise you.

There are a lot of people out there who have unrealistic expectations about dating and relationships. And they always think that they’re too good for someone or someone is too good for them.

It’s not like that at all! Relationships are about love and attraction, not about who’s better than the other.

Just because someone is good-looking and talented, it doesn’t mean that he himself is a good person.

Remember: relationships are about two people who want to be with each other. And if they’re good enough for each other, then they’re good enough for you!

17) She’s perfect for me.

Lastly, he might be thinking things like this after the first date:

  • “I’ll never find anyone like her.” 
  • “I could never love anyone else.”

If that’s the case, then congratulations, because you’re the perfect girl for him. What does it mean?

Your relationship is going to continue in the way you wanted to.

He likes you. He adores you. And your first day was a success.

You know what to do next: write him a note, send him a text or call him. And don’t forget to smile!

Final thoughts

In a nutshell, guys always think about the first date. As you see, they might think that you’re an ideal partner, but sometimes they believe they’re better than you. But don’t worry, because there’s a way to change his perspective.

I touched on the hero instinct earlier – it’s the perfect remedy for the situation you’re facing. 


Because once a man’s hero instinct is triggered, he’ll only have eyes for you. You’ll reach a part of him that no woman has ever managed to reach before. 

And in return, he’ll be compelled to commit to you and love you like he’s never loved another woman. 

So if you’re ready to take that plunge and reach new heights in your relationship, make sure to check out relationship expert James Bauer’s invaluable advice.

Click here to watch the excellent free video.

Can a relationship coach help you too?

If you want specific advice on your situation, it can be very helpful to speak to a relationship coach.

I know this from personal experience…

A few months ago, I reached out to Relationship Hero when I was going through a tough patch in my relationship. After being lost in my thoughts for so long, they gave me a unique insight into the dynamics of my relationship and how to get it back on track.

If you haven’t heard of Relationship Hero before, it’s a site where highly trained relationship coaches help people through complicated and difficult love situations.

In just a few minutes you can connect with a certified relationship coach and get tailor-made advice for your situation.

I was blown away by how kind, empathetic, and genuinely helpful my coach was.

Click here to get started.