25 ways to decide between two guys when you like them both

We sometimes include products we think are useful for our readers. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission. Read our affiliate disclosure.


Dating two men at the same time? Well, now’s your chance to have some fun! 

It feels like a good idea to date both of them simultaneously, but you might be feeling very conflicted.

You can’t decide who you should pick and who you should dump as they are both really special. They would be so perfect for you but they are also two very different people, so, how do you decide between the two? 

Well, depending on what makes more sense for your life, here are 25 questions to help you reach a decision.

1) Does he treat you right?

Here’s the first question, which one of them treats you the way you deserve to be treated?

If you are dating more than one man at a time, it’s obviously impossible to date two guys who will treat you both equally well since they are different people after all. 

Let me point it out more:

What one man does for you might not be what the other will do for you. 

Both men have their own characteristics and thus, their own way of showing love. 

If one treats you well, that’s great, but if both do, choose the man who treats you right most.

2) Is he serious about you?

This is really important. 

A man who is able to show a lot of commitment towards you, who loves being with you and talking about your relationship and future life, will be someone worth dating. 

Here are some simple ways that he’s showing his commitment to you:

  • He introduces you to his friends and family.
  • He talks about your future together.
  • He wants to be with you all the time.
  • He wants to meet your parents or family.
  • He is willing to sacrifice things he wants for you as long as it’s in your best interest. 

So, if he’s showing a lot of commitment, that’s a good man right there who will treat you well.

The perfect man would be someone who is both committed, loyal and reliable. 

If a guy does all of those things for you, you may want to consider him your boyfriend.

3) Is he funny?

You know how you feel when you’re with each of these guys. 

All in all, which man makes you feel more exciting, more exhilarating and happier? That’s the one who loves making you happy the most.

This is a very important factor to consider.  

A guy who can make you laugh and be playful will be a lot more fun to be with than an uptight guy who doesn’t really have any sense of humor at all. 

It’s time to ask yourself which one of the guys who likes to take you out for some nice walks on the beach or for some ice cream by the park? 

The man you will choose should be someone you can have fun with.

4) What would a gifted advisor say? 

The signs above and below in this article will give you a good idea of which man is the right one for you.

Even so, it can be very worthwhile to speak to a gifted person and get guidance from them. They can answer all sorts of relationship questions and take away your doubts and worries.

Like, is one of them could be your soulmate? Which of the two men is meant to be with you?

I recently spoke to someone from Psychic Source after going through a rough patch in my relationship. After being lost in my thoughts for so long, they gave me a unique insight into where my life was going, including who I was meant to be with.

I was actually blown away by how kind, compassionate and knowledgeable they were.

Click here to get your own love reading.

In a love reading, a gifted advisor can tell you whether you are choosing the right man, and most importantly empower you to make the right decisions when it comes to love.

5) Is he nice to your family?

Your Mr. Right should be someone who adores not only you but also the people that are important to you. Your parents, your siblings or your relatives are important to you just as much as he is. 

So who among these two men is making efforts to make them like him? 

Or, if he has already made a good impression on them, he should be keeping up the good work!

How a man interacts with your family tells so much about him:

  • Is he respectful of your parents?
  • Does he show them courtesy?
  • Does he listen to what they have to say?
  • Is he getting along with your siblings or relatives?

Think about which one of them is doing genuine efforts to be at your family’s good side.

6) Is he someone you’d like to have as a friend?

A guy who is a good match for you should be someone who makes you feel welcome at any time, listens to your problems or sentiments and makes you feel loved. 

He should be someone who is a good friend to you, too. 

If one of the two men makes you happy at difficult times and the other one doesn’t, take note of this since a friend that cheers you up when you are down is someone worth having around for life. 

Keep this in mind, you don’t want to pick someone who just wants to get in bed with you but someone who cares for your happiness as much as he cares about his own.

7) Does he have similar personalities to you?

Let’s be honest here.

Two people with a lot of similarities are more compatible than two people with different personalities. 

When you choose to date both of them, it can make the relationships much more difficult, so it’s better to try and find out which of them has similarities with you first.

The person who is more similar to you, the one with whom you are in most agreement with will be someone who shares your values and believes in the same things as you do.

With that in mind, there is a big chance for this man to make a perfect match for you.

8) Is he trustworthy?

Psychological research has proven that people are more likely to choose a partner who comes from a family and community with similar moral standards.

A man with a good reputation will be more likely to stand by what he says and be someone who is trustworthy and reliable.

If you want to build a long-term relationship, you should consider this factor the most.

Your choice should be someone who has substance:

  • a man who you can trust wholeheartedly
  • a man without any air of suspicions around him
  • a man that makes you feel safe in his arms

I know it will be hard to earn your trust, but you have all the time to build a trusting relationship with the right man.

9) Is he someone you feel attracted to?

At the same time, your choice should be someone who is physically attractive to you. 

Which one of them dresses to impress you?

Which one catches your eye? 

A man who makes an effort to look good or dress well will be more likely to leave an impression on you than a man who is shabby. 

You may want to be reminded that being physically attractive is one of the most important aspects when it comes to choosing a partner at the beginning of the relationship.

Your Mr. Right doesn’t need to have a very unique sense of style or be exceptionally physically attractive. 

But he should have enough value for himself to look good in your eyes and to other people. 

10) Who is a little calmer?

A man who’s able to stay cool under pressure when things get out of control is someone you can be calm with. If he’s calm, you won’t have many worries or anxious thoughts. 

When your relationship gets complicated, you will be able to communicate without any problems. 

Not only that, it will be much easier for him to calm you down.

Think about who among these two men is more able to stay cool and handle a situation calmly and rationally. 

11) Is he also a leader?

Don’t you want a man who steps forward when situations become complicated and knows how to handle a relationship?

A man who’s able to make decisions and take charge of the relationship is someone you can trust to watch over your relationship.

And the best part? 

You will feel protected when you are with this man. 

This is especially important to know if your man has a bad temper or mood swings. Since you will be pleased that someone is looking after both of you and preventing unnecessary arguments or fights. 

Think about who among these two men is a little more capable of taking control of the relationship.

12) What does your gut tell you?

Ask yourself what you feel about these two men. 

When you’re with them, how do you feel? 

  • Do you feel good or bad around them?   
  • Do they make you feel better or worse?
  • Are they bringing out the best in situations? or,
  • Are they bringing out the worst? 

All of these questions will help you decide which one of them is right for you. 

Listen to your gut, and if you have any feelings that give you a clue as to which one is best, pay attention to those feelings.

But if there’s a way to know if your gut feelings are 100% sure, would you take it?

I mentioned earlier how the help of a gifted advisor can reveal the truth about the right man in your life.

You could analyze the signs until you reach the conclusion you’re looking for, but getting guidance from a gifted person will give you real clarity on the situation.

I know from experience how helpful it can be. When I was going through a similar problem to you, they gave me the guidance I sorely needed. 

Click here to get your own love reading

13) Which one of them is willing to wait for your relationship?

Write down how long each of these two men has been waiting for the relationship to develop. 

Compare the two and determine who has more passion and commitment for the relationship. 

This is one of the most important things you should consider before choosing a man.

You see, there are men who are not willing to wait for your relationship to develop. They just want to play with your feelings and break off when they feel like it.

If these two men have been waiting for more than two months, who do you think will be more faithful in their feelings?  

Who will show stronger desire and love for you?  

Maybe it’s time for you to answer these questions and make a choice.

14) Which one of them is more mature?

This factor is just a little bit different from the previous ones. 

Think about which of these two men has more wisdom to deal with situations in life. 

You see, there are men who have no experience and are not mature for their age. 

These kinds of guys will just try to impress you the first day and then forget about you as soon as you are no longer in their attention. 

They’ll use you for their own pleasures, telling you sweet lies and then maybe running off with another girl as soon as they can.

Compare which of these two men can be trusted with your feelings. 

You have the chance to look at their past experiences, see how they handle future events, and see if they are able to take responsibility for their lives. 

This is a difficult question to answer, but it’s very important to know. 

If a man can’t take responsibility for his own life, then he can’t necessarily be trusted with yours. 

15) Which one of them is more passionate?

It’s not the same thing as being passionate about the relationship. 

You see, passion is much more than love or lust. 

If you are able to understand his passion, then you can see how he deals with issues in life. 

How easily can he solve things? Or what kind of issues can he handle without having to give up? 

It takes a lot of passion to achieve goals that are difficult to achieve.

If a man has a lot of passion, you will be able to feel the excitement and motivation in him when he talks about certain things.

16) Does he compliment you?

A man who knows how to compliment his woman is someone who’s thoughtful and caring.

Compliments are also one of the best ways to get close to your partner. 

If you’re able to hear compliments from him, he understands how lucky he is to date an attractive woman like you and acknowledges your existence in his life. 

It can make you feel good about yourself and, more importantly, it can help boost your confidence so that you can become the right woman for him. 

You see, anyone can give compliments when they are trying to get a girl into bed with them. 

It’s not about how many compliments he gives but how genuine his compliments are for you. 

So, which one of them shows his admiration for you?

17) Who is more romantic?

Let’s admit it. 

A relationship is more than just love and care. It’s about having fun and feeling excited about the person you are with. 

And this is where romance comes in. 

A man who knows how to romance his woman will show how honored he feels by being with her, which makes the relationship head on the right path.

Romance has a magic power to make both people happy, especially when the two of you are in a relationship together. 

Most women are attracted to a man who can romance them, and if you’re the type of woman who is always looking for romance in your life, then you need to be in a relationship with a man who knows how to bring it out in you.

18) Which one of them has a higher income?

Obviously, you need someone who can take care of you. 

Here is the question: 

Which one of these men has a monthly income that is higher than yours? 

If you’ve been seeing them enough to know that they’re earning almost the same amount, then let’s continue with another question.    

How long do they expect their work to pay? 

You see, there are men who don’t expect to have a high income if they stay in their current job, but there are others who don’t think like that. 

They have big dreams and look at themselves as having high incomes in the future.

So choose the man who’s ambitious enough to be able to afford to treat you to romantic dates, exciting vacations, new experiences, or even spoil you once in a while. 

19) Have you asked your closest friends yet?

I know that you want to make a decision quickly, because there are many other things you want and don’t want to happen before the relationship gets deeper. 

But remember that picking a man is not just about attraction and desire.  

It’s also about compatibility, spending time together, and even your future.  

So try to ask the people closest to you for their advice first. They can see you in a different light, look at you with a more neutral perspective, and give you the best advice they can.

Plus, these people will be happy to help you. 

It’s one of their roles in your life. They are there to protect you from making mistakes, so try asking them about your relationship situation before it’s too late. 

20) Do you think one of them can be your soulmate?

How easy it is to date someone who you think can be your soulmate. 

But which one of these men? 

It is highly possible that you’re already seeing your soulmate, you feel it in your guts and the Universe is leading him to you too.

Want to know for certain whether you’ve met your soulmate?

Let’s face it:

We can waste a lot of time and energy with people who ultimately we’re not compatible with. Finding your soulmate isn’t exactly easy.

But what if there was a way to remove all the guesswork?

I’ve just stumbled upon a way to do this…  a professional psychic artist who can draw a sketch of what your soulmate looks like.

Even though I was a bit skeptical at first, my friend convinced me to try it out a few weeks ago.

Now I know exactly what he looks like. The crazy thing is that I recognized him right away,

If you’re ready to find out what your soulmate looks like, get your own sketch drawn here.

21) Do you see any red flags?

I mean, a guy can be really great at first but may “go downhill” for many reasons. 

What about the red flags

Is he cheating, lying, or has a lot of anger issues

It’s important to know this before jumping head first into the relationship. 

While these three things can happen in any relationship, they have a greater chance of happening with someone you’re going to be in love with too! 

So, you may want to take note and pay attention to those red flags if you’re looking for that perfect man

22) Can you imagine your life with him?

Life is too short and unpredictable. 

You can always hope that things will turn out the way you want them to be, but there’s always a chance that things don’t work out. 

That’s scary, but it will also make you realize that everything happens for a reason in this world. 

Even if he doesn’t seem like the perfect fit for your longer-term plans, if he really makes you happy at the moment and makes you smile every day, then at least enjoy life as it comes your way.

This man’s face is who you want to see each and every day. 

Now as you are reading at this point, who came into your mind?

Who did you just imagine to be a part of your future?

23) Is he interested in your life story?

There are two ways to tell when a guy is into you. 

One is when he asks you about your past and even about the type of people that you hang out with or go to school or work with. 

This guy is interested in your life story. 

He may find it exciting and interesting to hear that you love going on trips around the world and even living with your parents for a few years before moving out and getting a job.

And the second one is the total opposite: he doesn’t really ask, he’s not really interested, or he creates questions just to make a conversation flow.

This guy is not really into your life as much as you are into him.

Take some time to think about who has been showing interest in your past, life, or even future plans. 

24) Who brings out the best in you?

Knowing who brings out the best in you is a very important thing. 

It’s not always easy to tell someone that they’re making you a better person, even if they are – don’t avoid that because it might get ugly in the long term.

Also, remember that there’s always an element of risk involved in a relationship. 

In some relationships, you might feel safe with this person and don’t want to break up for whatever reason. 

But in the end, you may find that he’s not really the best for you. 

So, it’s better to think about how this man makes you a better person.

Make sure you choose someone who’s not only great for your life but also for your mind and soul because at the end of the day, we’re all looking for someone to complement or even complete us.

25) Do you feel like a queen when you’re with this man? 

I know that this is a very hard question to answer, as it could sound self-centered to other people.

You may have no idea how to answer this question because you’ve never been in this situation before. 

But there is something you need to know: 

This question is like asking if your knight in shining armor is right before your eyes.

Here’s something to think about: if he makes you feel like a queen, he is definitely a keeper

A man who can make you feel so special, so loved and appreciated will always treat you with respect and kindness.

He will give his all to protect your heart and soul, because he knows that love is not just about two people who are attracted to each other. 

Final thoughts

I hope that, with these tips, you can be more prepared to find the man of your dreams, who will make you feel so happy and cherished every day. 

My best advice is that you need to avoid being rushed in any decision because it will only end up hurting you in the long run. 

So take your time and make sure to choose a man who is right for you. And be sure to have fun while finding out who he is.

However, if you really want to find out who is the right one for you, don’t leave it up to chance. 

Instead speak to a gifted advisor who will give you the answers you’re searching for. 

I mentioned Psychic Source earlier.

When I got a reading from them, I was surprised at how knowledgeable and understanding they were. They helped me out when I needed it the most and that’s why I always recommend their services to anyone facing problems or confusions with their love life. 

Click here to get your own professional love reading. 

Can a relationship coach help you too?

If you want specific advice on your situation, it can be very helpful to speak to a relationship coach.

I know this from personal experience…

A few months ago, I reached out to Relationship Hero when I was going through a tough patch in my relationship. After being lost in my thoughts for so long, they gave me a unique insight into the dynamics of my relationship and how to get it back on track.

If you haven’t heard of Relationship Hero before, it’s a site where highly trained relationship coaches help people through complicated and difficult love situations.

In just a few minutes you can connect with a certified relationship coach and get tailor-made advice for your situation.

I was blown away by how kind, empathetic, and genuinely helpful my coach was.

Click here to get started.